Nailing It or Failing It? Free Expert Feedback on Your Interview Questions.
Click Here
Logo Informed Decisions Interview Intelligence
Subscription Form
The blog
September 30, 2025
Why Are Interviews Broken? Reason #2 (and How to Fix It)
Share This Article

Prioritizing confidence over competence.

Here's what we learned from analyzing thousands of interviews: 

The #1 predictor of high interview scores? 

"Effective communication" - basically, how well candidates sell their story.

And it gets worse:

The Dunning-Kruger effect shows that less competent people often overestimate their abilities, while true experts tend to underrate themselves.

Picture this:

Candidate A: A brilliant developer who understates their achievements Candidate B: An average coder who tells captivating stories about their limited experience

Who gets hired more often? You guessed it - Candidate B.

Here's how to fix it:

3 Ways to Test Real Skills, Not Just Talk:

  • Run skills-based, structured interviews that measure specific abilities through relevant questions.
  • During the interview, ask candidates to solve real problems, not just describe past solutions.
  • Include work samples that mirror actual job tasks.

Stop hiring the best storytellers. Start hiring the best performers.

Stay tuned for Reason #3

Logo Informed Decisions Interview Intelligence
AICPA SOC logo
Address: 20 Tuval St. Ramat Gan, Israel
All rights reserved to Informed Decisions LTD. © 2025
crosschevron-down linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram