Nailing It or Failing It? Free Expert Feedback on Your Interview Questions.
Click Here
Logo Informed Decisions Interview Intelligence
Subscription Form
The blog
October 14, 2025
The #1 Factor That Makes Candidates Leave Positive Interview Feedback (Even When Rejected)
Share This Article

Last week, we asked what would make you leave positive feedback on a company's interview process, even if you were rejected.

Drum roll for the results:

Almost 50% of respondents would leave positive feedback simply because they had a respectful experience!

And over a third prioritized transparent feedback about their rejection.

 

What Does "Respectful and Pleasant" Actually Mean?

Here's a practical checklist for creating this experience at each stage:

 

Before the Interview

  • Provide clear information about the role, process, and timeline upfront
  • Respond to all applications, even with automated acknowledgments
  • Give candidates adequate notice for scheduling interviews
  • Share who they will be interviewing with (roles and names)
  • Send preparation materials and agenda before the interview
  • Clarify what type of questions they'll be asked (technical, behavioral, etc.)
  • Make accommodations available for those who need them

During the Interview

  • Start on time and introduce everyone present
  • Explain the format and expectations at the beginning
  • Ask relevant questions that allow candidates to showcase their skills
  • Provide water and breaks during lengthy interviews
  • Genuinely listen to responses
  • Be present and engaged (no checking emails or multitasking)
  • Don't create unnecessary stress by being tough or creating fake stressful situations that candidates won't experience in their day-to-day work - the interview is stressful enough as it is
  • End with clear next steps and timeline

After the Interview

  • Follow up when promised
  • Provide specific, constructive feedback about their performance (36% of candidates specifically want this!)
  • Express appreciation for their time and interest
  • Offer to keep in touch for future opportunities if appropriate
  • Ask for their feedback on the interview process

Remember: The interview process is a two-way street.

Even rejected candidates become brand ambassadors who share their experiences with others.

Question for you: What was the most respectful and pleasant interview experience you've had, and what made it stand out?

Logo Informed Decisions Interview Intelligence
AICPA SOC logo
Address: 20 Tuval St. Ramat Gan, Israel
All rights reserved to Informed Decisions LTD. © 2025
crosschevron-down linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram